Over the course of the next three days I’ll be posting a series of essays regarding entertainment – specifically, what God says about it in His Word. These essays were the result of a lot of serious and prayerful thought, and are – I hope – firmly founded in Scripture. They are the direct result of a painful process in which God transformed the way I evaluate my entertainment.
—
Garbage In, Garbage Out
By Richard W Rohlin
“People will know you,” the saying goes, “by the books you read and the friends you keep.” And there’s a lot of truth in that, to be sure. If you looked at a person’s list of their favorite books it would tell you a lot about them — their personalities, interests, even dreams and desires. If that list included, say, a lot of mystery/adventure books then obviously the person who reads them has an inclination or longing towards excitement and intrigue. If that list consisted of philosophical treatises like Hobbes’s Leviathan or Plato’s Republic, it would indicate a keen interest in government theory and a bent towards things of that nature.
What most people โ most Christians โ are reticent to admit, though, is that the books you read don’t just tell about the kind of person you are. According to Scripture they can actually affect your character.
1 Corinthians 15:33 tells us to “Be not deceived: evil communications corrupt good manners.” The word “communication” means companionship or intercourse. “Manners” is the word ethos (ay-thos) — a word we use in modern times to describe the whole attitude and way of doing things. If a primitive culture is built entirely around the warrior as a central social class, we say that culture is founded upon a pervading warrior ethos. That is precisely what is meant here — a “way of doing things” if you will. Roughly paraphrased into modern English, then, “Don’t be fooled: evil companions, communication, or intercourse ruin a moral way of life.”
The context of the passage here is also important: 1 Corinthians 15 addresses the problem of some people teaching that there is no resurrection of the dead. Paul pauses in the midst of his arguments against this heresy to point out this falsehood is something that we need to stay away from because error is always corrupting. I believe the principle applies to other aspects of our walk with the Lord as well — the kind of “communication” we allow ourselves to be exposed to will affect the person we are. It will affect the way we live our lives.
This has a lot of applications. Obviously this applies to the friendships we keep. But what about entertainment? Every form of entertainment is simply a form of communication. Music is communication of ideas, feelings, and thoughts expressed through a combination of melody, harmony, and rhythm. Art, reading material, television, movies… They all communicate somebody’s worldview. So if these are all forms of communication and if communication can be good or bad… Then it is logical that the books we read and other mediums of entertainment we allow in our life affect us on a fundamental level.
What about a book or series of books that glorifies something which Scripture condemns such as witchcraft? What about a movie that promotes loose moral standards and makes light of things such as curses and the undead? What about a TV show that propagates situational ethics and wanton violence? An enjoyable science fiction series that operates upon the basis that evolution is real? Are these things that we can put before our eyes without it affecting our walk with the Lord — our way of life?
What I am hitting at here is that a lot of Christians don’t realize or don’t want to realize that the kind of stuff they expose themselves to is going to affect them — whether they want to admit it or not. We need to purpose, as the Psalmist said, to “set no wicked thing” before our eyes. (Psalm 101:3).
There’s a maxim in computer programming which I believe states much more eloquently than I have here the point I am trying to make:
Garbage in, garbage out.
benjc91
February 8, 2010
Okay, I have to say this:
RIGHT ON bro! I have recently been extremely challenged on the subject, and came to the same(however FAR less elequently stated) conclusion. The Bible commands us to “Flee youthful lusts” (2 Timothy 2:22)
I have been trying to explain this to a friend of mine, and it turned to quite a heated (but polite) debate. We are now in the process of exporting the debate from Facebook to our respective Jibenow blogs… anyways, I was getting quite frustrated until a friend of mine gave me a link to your blog. I’m so glad he did. ๐
Keep it up, man! ๐ God bless!
– Ben
jacob
February 8, 2010
Hum, interesting position but I have a couple questions about it…
First, you assume that every song, movie, book, or anything devised for the soul purpose of entertainment, is actually “promoting” something, or in other words, has some underlying agenda. Can you really claim that about all movies/music/books contain this???
Second, you insinuate essentially that we will be influenced by all that we watch/listen-to/or read. Jesus spent time in fellowship with his heavenly father, he also spent time with the tax collectors and sinners of his day. He was not influenced by the latter because he spent much time with the former. The same applies to music, movies, or books. If you have a solid grounding in scripture, and a well developed relation ship with God, then there is no material threat to watching/listing/reading these movies/music/books. How do you reconcile this with condemning, or at the very least rejecting, any form of entertainment that doesn’t line up with your world view?
scottishclaymore
February 8, 2010
1) All entertainment is essentially communication. Communication always has a message. Can you give me an example of a form of entertainment which does NOT communicate some kind of message? Notice that there is also a difference between a “message” and an agenda. Agendas are intentional, while messages are not always so.
2) It isn’t my world view that’s in question here — rather it is that taught by Scripture. As for the rest of your question… I have to fundamentally disagree with the statement, “If you have a solid grounding in scripture, and a well developed relation ship with God, then there is no material threat to watching/listing/reading these movies/music/books.” This is wrong on a number of levels. Check out Haggai 2:12-14 – the clean does not make the unclean thing clean. No amount of holiness will protect me from the harm of looking at pornography, because it is wrong for me to do so and it is hurtful to my soul.
In closing I’d recommend you wait for the next essay in the series – this first one was simply laying foundational principles. I think many of your questions about practical applications will be answered.
jacob
February 9, 2010
I just have to clarify one thing. I don’t think that the clean, makes the unclean, clean. You seem to be asserting that because something doesn’t line up perfectly with your world view, that it is therefore unclean or anti-your world view… this isn’t so. I don’t know about you but I enjoyed the movie โDark Nightโ. It doesn’t line up in anyway with my world view but it is entertaining and I enjoy it. No, it didn’t change my view of anything, because having a scriptural basis for what I believe, I knew when something was wrong and not to accept it. Watching movies doesn’t change a persons position unless they are vulnerable to it. I’m in no way an iron man, but God does give us levels of under standing, and protection against influences that would lead us astray. If we are not impaired in our walk with Christ through our enjoyment of a movie, a song, or a book, then no harm is done through enjoying that which God has provided to opportunity to enjoy. In that context, no one disputes the negative affect porn has…
scottishclaymore
February 9, 2010
1) Once again, it is not my worldview that is in question here, nor do I completely and entirely rule out certain things because they have disagreeable elements. The point of this essay is that evil communication corrupts good manners. That is not my worldview – that is what Scripture says.
2) In this particular essay I merely lay forth what Scripture says about the things that influence us, and challenge the reader to apply those principles to every area of their life. If you have a balancing truth to present, please do so from Scripture.
brianfactor
February 10, 2010
Once again, Richard, I’m concerned about the mindset here. We are free in Christ. All things are clean for us. The reasoning for not choosing to do something should not be that it is unholy, but because it is unprofitable.
Allow me to use several verses to directly contradict your argument here:
Roman 14: 14, 22: “As one who is in the Lord Jesus, I am fully convinced that no food is unclean in itself. But if anyone regards something as unclean, then for him it is unclean. […] So whatever you believe about these things keep between yourself and God. Blessed is the man who does not condemn himself by what he approves.”
Acts 10:15: “Do not call anything impure that God has made clean.”
Titus 1:15 “To the pure, all things are pure, but to those who are corrupted and do not believe, nothing is pure.”
The biggest issue here is food, but I think that you can see from these passages (as well as my quick discussion of 1 Cor 8 on the other post) that this applies to all areas: all things are legal, but not all things are profitable. (1 Cor 10:23)
So, I really think you should shift your discussion of the “cleanness” of certain media to a discussion of the “profitability” for a Christian of these forms of entertainment. Have I finally made my point clear? I think it’s been kinda murky…
><> Brian
scottishclaymore
February 10, 2010
Thanks for a thought-out and carefully written comment, Brian. I have a number of responses, but first let me preface them with a question: going back to the issue or pornography: Is it merely unprofitable, or is it morally wrong?
Admin
February 10, 2010
Fantastic discussion guys. This is precisely one of the reasons Jibe was made… for people to think about tough (and advanced) ideas.
Brian JM
February 12, 2010
“Is it merely unprofitable, or is it morally wrong?”
Technically speaking, if you could view porn without lust, there would be nothing wrong with it. But good luck with that…
Same principle as there’s nothing inherently wrong with nudity, but God still wants us to be clothed. I guess you could say porn is not morally wrong; lust is. For all but one person, porn leads to lust, which is why you could also say it’s wrong.
So, where are you going with this?
><> Brian
scottishclaymore
February 15, 2010
Brian,
Thanks for answering the question. I’ll respond in the next blog post. Please continue to comment. ๐